The coronavirus pandemic has touched all facets of life, and the criminal justice system is no exception.
Arrests and criminal citations filed in the Cape’s two largest district courts are down by more than 20 percent in 2020, when the pandemic began.
The inmate population at the Barnstable County House of Corrections is down over 200 inmates from what it typically averages.
The reasons for the changes vary, from people staying off the streets because of the Governor’s emergency order to sheriff’s releasing inmates who may be at risk for the coronavirus and nearing the end of the sentence.
In Barnstable District Court, there were 2,264 criminal arrests and summonses for 2020. There are typically about 2,800 at the Cape’s largest district courthouse. In 2019 there were 2,723; in 2018, there was 2,823, a difference of about 20 percent compared to 2020.
In the Falmouth District Court, the reduction was even bigger. There were 2,059 arrests and summonses in 2019 and 2,161 in 2018. But just 1,340 in 2020.
Court and prison officials in Barnstable County say that closing down bars at 9:30pm across the state and people heeding the Governor’s orders and staying home can explain the reduction in criminal citations. They say that not as many people are staying out late, and therefore aren’t getting pulled over for things like OUIs and other offenses.
First assistant attorney for the Cape and Islands Michael Trudeau said that the pandemic is also having an impact on policing.
Some police departments have moved staff off their typical beat and are putting them on reserve. That way, if there is an outbreak in the department, they will have officers who haven’t been infected and can work a shift. But that could mean fewer officers on the street at a given time.
Meanwhile, the inmate population at the Barnstable County House of Corrections is down considerably as well.
Prior to the pandemic, Sheriff James Cummings says the prison averaged about 425 inmates. But recently, that dropped to 173 inmates.
Cummings says a big factor to this reduced population is the fact that no jury trials are happening now.
The state has suspended jury trials because of the pandemic. It’s difficult bringing together a jury while also keeping everyone safe. With no jury trails, many defendants are awaiting their trial at home.
Another explanation for the reduced inmate population, Cummings says, is that his department has worked with the Cape and Islands district attorney’s office to release some inmates with a limited time left to serve on their sentence, and who had a small bail they couldn’t pay.
Judges are also weighing the health of a defendant when they issue a sentence. If a defendant has diabetes, or is overweight, an attorney can make a case to the judge that their client is at health risk and deservers a shorter sentence. Or they’ll argue that their client should serve under house arrest or wear an ankle bracelet instead.
Trudeau says he understands why judges are making this decision.
“If there’s an individual with five or six weeks left on a sentence, and they could roll that into a home confinement or GPS parole situation, I don’t think that’s necessarily unwarranted,” Trudeau said.
Trudeau also says the pandemic has been hard for families of victims who are waiting for justice, but he says they understand the complications with the pandemic.
There are still some court proceedings happening, such as arraignments and pre-trail conferences, as well as cases argued in front of a judge, rather than a jury. That’s taking place over Zoom.
Barnstable District Court First Justice John Julian says virtual court proceedings certainly are different, but he says there are some advantages. He says that it actually has kept the docket down and allowed judges to focus on more serious parts of a case. Defense attorneys and prosecutors are able to negotiate some pre-trial discussions outside of the courthouse. Prior to the pandemic, those negotiations can really slow down a case.
But Judge Julian says that the downside is he can’t have the same interaction with a defendant or an attorney arguing a case over a screen, compared to the traditional court setting.
And he says that can be tough when weighing someone’s credibility. “When people are in front of you, you can size them up. You can read their body language,” he says. “Now they’re in their living rooms or bedrooms, or still in their pajamas, in much more comfortable setting where they don’t have to look a judge in the eye.”
As for when things may get back to normal at the local courts, the state has begun phase 1 of the return for jury trials in person. That started in early January. There have only been a handful of jury trials so far in the whole state.
Like much of the rest of everyday life, court officials say that bringing back jury trials is reliant on the vaccine.
Defense attorneys, prosecutors, judges, clerks and other court officers are all scheduled for the later part of the second phase of the vaccine. When the vaccination will move past residents 75 and older is still unclear.