Rural Hospitals Brace For Coronavirus | WCAI

Rural Hospitals Brace For Coronavirus

Mar 15, 2020
Originally published on March 15, 2020 3:29 pm

In Grangeville, Idaho, population 3,000, Syringa Hospital has just 15 beds, an emergency room and a clinic. As is common in rural medicine, the chief medical officer, Dr. Matthew Told, is also a family practice OB and, on a recent evening, the on-call ER doc.

"We don't have ventilator services, we don't have respiratory therapy," Told says during a break between seeing patients.

There is no intensive care unit. So when they do get a critically ill patient or trauma victims, it's standard protocol to stabilize and transfer them to a large regional hospital in western Montana or Spokane, Wash. But what if ICUs in those places become overwhelmed with coronavirus patients?

"The biggest challenge is living so close to a state where there are so many cases, such as Washington, and having that really just across the border," Told says.

Told knows that his hospital could soon be completely overwhelmed and unable to effectively treat anyone, coronavirus patient or not. This is the story in many communities right now. But it could have an even more dire effect in isolated rural towns like this that lack the infrastructure or trained staff, especially if they were to get sick and couldn't come to work.

Syringa is one of Grangeville's largest employers.

"If the places that you rely on to send your critically ill patients are full, then you're stuck," says Dr. Mark Deutchman, associate dean for rural health at the University of Colorado's medical school.

Deutchman says people living in more isolated rural areas may be less at risk for contracting the virus because of the sheer lack of people or large gatherings, yet the lack of resources is a perennial challenge during any public health crisis.

Michelle Schaeffer, director of Syringa Clinics in Idaho, says her facility and an adjoining hospital have about a month's supply of masks left.
Kirk Siegler / NPR

Hospital officials in Grangeville say dealing with obstacles and getting creative is a fact of life in rural medicine. For now, their triage plan is to likely block off the ER from the rest of the hospital via a plastic wall. That would at least give them two more isolation beds. They're also asking patients who may show symptoms of COVID-19 to stay in their cars outside the ER initially, where they can be evaluated and masked.

Michelle Schaeffer, the director at the Syringa clinic, says the single biggest concern right now is they only have about a month's supply left of masks.

"It doesn't help that we go to — what is it, an hour and a half to Lewiston? — to our nearest Walmart and there's not even toilet paper on the shelves because people are panicking," she says.

So they're pushing what they see as their most effective tool still at their disposal to fight the spread of the virus in their community: prevention. "So that it never actually gets into the walls of this hospital," Schaeffer says.

Hospital staff armed with pamphlets and prevention talking points are visiting local businesses, nursing homes and schools. Schools are often the center of small-town life, but they're also a petri dish for spreading viruses, says Nathan Winder, a physician assistant who sits on Syringa's infection prevention committee.

Physician assistant Nathan Winder talks to Grangeville, Idaho-area fourth-graders about proper hand-washing and germ-fighting techniques.
Kirk Siegler / NPR

One recent afternoon, clutching a spray bottle as a prop, Winder demonstrated hygiene to an attentive class of fourth-graders at Grangeville Elementary. Most of the kids were aware of the coronavirus, and several said they were already touching elbows instead of doing hand shakes or high fives. Some also boasted they knew to sing most of the popular Baby Shark song while washing their hands.

"And when you cough, cover it with your elbow," Winder reminded them.

Many of the prevention protocols are similar to what health experts already push during bad influenza outbreaks. Winder left the class feeling encouraged.

"The kids already know a lot," he said. "You can tell they want to do the right thing, they want to not spread the germs, they don't want to get sick, they've all been sick."

But hospital officials say this may be the easiest demographic to convince that there is a serious health crisis looming. Like in a lot of rural America, Grangeville's population skews older. You'll also tend to find an inherent mistrust toward institutions and the government in rural Idaho, where there are already lower than average vaccination rates.

Conspiracy theories and misinformation are said to be spreading like wildfire on social media. And it's clear some people just aren't that worried.

Outside Cloninger's Supermarket, Jennifer Rogers said she sees the coronavirus as just another bad flu with inconvenient symptoms.

"To me, it feels political," Rogers says. "It's an election year and there's always something big that happens during an election year."

For now, Rogers said she isn't doing anything out of the ordinary to prepare.

"I mean, if it were close to home and I knew somebody and I could see their reactions and it was super bad, then it would obviously heighten my awareness," she said.

But nearby, Gail Solveria traded a handshake for an elbow bump and said she was stocking up with a two-week supply of groceries and medicine should there be a need to isolate. People around here are used to having to be prepared for things like bad weather, she said. And Solveria works as a caregiver for a 93-year-old man.

"We're trying not to fear, you know, and stay level-headed and trust in God," she said.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

LULU GARCIA-NAVARRO, HOST:

Rural America - wide, open spaces, sunshine and the wind off the fields. Could people living there be at less risk for contracting the coronavirus? No. Health officials say that's not possible in today's global society, and small towns are beginning to report cases. NPR's Kirk Siegler went to a small Idaho hospital close to the Washington border.

KIRK SIEGLER, BYLINE: Here in Grangeville, Idaho, population 3,000, the Syringa Hospital has just 15 beds, an emergency room and a clinic. As is common in rural medicine, the chief medical officer here, Dr. Matthew Told, is also a family practice OB. And today, he's the on-call ER doc. There is no ICU.

MATTHEW TOLD: We don't have ventilatory services. We don't have respiratory therapy.

SIEGLER: So when they do get a critically ill patient or trauma victims, it's standard protocol to stabilize and transfer them to a large regional hospital in western Montana or Spokane, Wash. But what if ICUs there become overwhelmed with coronavirus patients?

TOLD: The biggest challenge is, you know, being - living so close to a state where there's so many cases that are there, such as Washington, and having that really just across the border.

SIEGLER: Told knows that Syringa Hospital could soon be completely overwhelmed and not able to effectively treat anyone, corona patient or not. This is the story in many communities right now, but it could have an even more dire effect in isolated rural towns like this that lack infrastructure and trained staff, especially if they get sick and can't come to work. Syringa is one of Grangeville's largest employers. So the triage plan for now is to likely block off the ER from the rest of the hospital via a plastic wall. That would at least give them two more isolation beds. Michelle Schaeffer is the Syringa clinic director. She says the single biggest concern right now is that they only have about a month's supply left of masks.

MICHELLE SCHAEFFER: It doesn't help that, you know, we go to - what is it? - an hour and a half to Lewiston to our nearest Walmart, and there's not even toilet paper on the shelves because people are panicking.

SIEGLER: So they're pushing their most effective tool in the community, prevention.

SCHAEFFER: And really make sure that we're educating them on the best way to prevent infection so that it never actually gets into the walls of this hospital.

SIEGLER: Hospital staff armed with pamphlets and prevention talking points are visiting local businesses, nursing homes and schools, the center of small town life.

NATHAN WINDER: There's a new virus you hear about. Maybe it'll come to here someday. What is it?

SIEGLER: Physician assistant Nathan Winder, who sits on Syringa's infection prevention committee, is at Grangeville Elementary, talking to this attentive class of fourth graders.

WINDER: When you cough, you cover it.

SIEGLER: Cough into your elbows. Sing the entire "Happy Birthday" song when you wash your hands, he says, a similar strategy when there's a bad flu outbreak.

WINDER: The kids already know a lot. You know, they're excited. You can tell they want to do the right thing. They want to not spread the germs. They don't want to get sick. They've all been sick.

SIEGLER: But hospital officials say this may be the easiest demographic to convince that there's a serious health crisis looming. Like in a lot of rural America, Grangeville's population skews older. You also find a lot of mistrust toward institutions and the government in rural Idaho, where there's already lower-than-average vaccination rates. People in Grangeville told me that conspiracy theories and misinformation are spreading like wildfire on social media. And some folks just aren't that worried.

JENNIFER ROGERS: To me, it feels political.

SIEGLER: Outside Cloninger's Supermarket, Jennifer Rogers sees corona as just another flu with its inconvenient symptoms.

ROGERS: I mean, if it were close to home and I knew somebody and I could see their reactions and it was super bad, then it would obviously heighten my awareness.

SIEGLER: But for now, Rogers says she isn't doing anything out of the ordinary to prepare.

Kirk Siegler, NPR News, Grangeville, Idaho. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.